Last Updated: 5:35 pm CST
Wednesday, March 10, 2010

 


*** Editor's Note: TheSequitur.com magazine indefinitely ceased publication in June 2009. ***


Navigation: Front Page arrow Confidential Sources

Confidential Sources
Locy contempt order temporarily blocked
Monday, 17 March 2008
According to USA Today:
A federal appeals court Tuesday temporarily blocked a judge's order requiring a former USA TODAY reporter to pay thousands of dollars in fines. Toni Locy would not identify sources who named former Army scientist Steven Hatfill as a possible suspect in the 2001 anthrax attacks.
Related: RCFP recently sent out a very detailed memo on the Locy situation.
Read more...
Locy contempt citation a ‘call to arms’ for journalists
Tuesday, 11 March 2008

Editor’s Note: Reproduced in its entirety below is an important press release from RCFP:

This memorandum is a call to arms to all American journalists from the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.

Late Friday, U.S. District Court Judge Reggie Walton in Washington, D.C. issued an order holding former USA TODAY reporter Toni Locy in contempt for refusing to reveal confidential sources in the Hatfill/anthrax stories she wrote about five years ago.

Judge Walton denied Locy's request for a stay pending appeal to the DC Circuit and ordered that all fines must come out of her pocket: she will not be allowed to accept assistance in paying the fines. In a couple of weeks, the fines will accelerate to $5,000 a day and not even her own mother will be allowed to help her pay them. Her first payment is due at midnight tomorrow.

Gannett Co. has filed a motion for an emergency stay of the contempt citation with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. A coalition of about two dozen media companies and non-profit journalism organizations has also filed an amicus brief in support of Locy.

In the meantime, the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press urges you to pay attention to this case. Accordingly, we have prepared this memo as background as you write stories and editorials about this outrageous situation. Below you will find useful links to copies of court pleadings and orders, helpful background on the proliferation of subpoenas in recent years in the federal courts and information about the status of proposed federal shield laws in Congress.

We'd appreciate your help in impressing upon journalists, lawmakers, and the public that this situation is untenable. As always, the Reporters Committee stands ready to help you. We can be reached at 703-807-2100.

A few bullet points for you:

  • No judge has ever officially ordered that a reporter held in contempt may not accept reimbursement from an employer (or anyone else.) Read the Reporters Committee's list of recent contempt citations nationwide.

  • Ms. Locy has cooperated to a degree. But she can't remember who her specific sources were, so the judge has ordered her to reveal the names of up to a dozen confidential sources she routinely relied upon in the Justice Department (many of them who were sources for stories more sensitive than this one.) Read her declaration, deposition and legal brief challenging the contempt citation.

  • The fine (up to $5,000 a day) is punitive. If the judge wants to punish Ms. Locy, he should try her for criminal contempt and let a jury find that she willfully, intentionally and criminally forgot who her sources were for these stories. Read plaintiff Hatfill's motions for sanctions against Ms. Locy and former CBS News reporter Jim Stewart.

  • The judge's order can be interpreted as unjustly and unfairly coercing Gannett to participate in a settlement with Hatfill. Because the media companies involved in the Wen Ho Lee case were willing to participate in a settlement with the government, Judge Walton believes he can force Gannett to the negotiating table to come up with part of the damages sought by Hatfill. Read a "White Paper" describing the threat to newsrooms of subpoenas in federal civil cases and a story describing the Wen Ho Lee settlement.

  • Some of the sources in this case have "self-identified." We know the Justice Department leaked the information. So what we're involved in here is essentially an effort to increase the financial settlement by trying to multiply the damages by keeping track of: (1) How many sources were involved, (2) How many times each spoke, and (3) How many different "facts" they revealed.

  • This case is a prime example of why we need a federal shield law. You can read the bills that are pending in the Senate and that passed the House, as well as a memo prepared by the Newspaper Association of America that describes them. Last week, Senators Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) and Arlen Specter (R-Pa.) urged Senate leadership to send the bill to the floor for a vote.

  • Journalists across the country need to cover this issue. To that end, we hope you will find the Reporters Committee's "Shields and Subpoenas" web page to be useful. You may also be curious as to how your own state handles subpoena issues; see The Reporters Committee compendium of state and federal reporters privilege laws.

  • The Reporters Committee continues to explore ways in which we can financially support Ms. Locy without violating the judge's order. We will keep you apprised of those efforts.

More news after the jump.

[RCFP]

Read more...
German law threatens journalists’ confidential sources
Sunday, 11 November 2007
According to IFEX:
The International Press Institute (IPI), the global network of editors, media executives and leading journalists in over 120 countries, expresses deep concern over a proposed amendment to Germany's telecommunications law that contains serious threats to press freedom.

According to information before IPI, the German Bundestag on 9 November will discuss a bill, introduced by Justice Minister Brigitte Zypries, requiring telecommunications providers to retain all customer communication data for a period of six months. If approved, starting on 1 January 2008, law enforcement bodies could gain access to these stored communications, which cover telephone calls, text messages, e-mails or faxes, in the course of their criminal investigations.
[IFEX]
Read more...

Your Ad Here
FireInATheater.com Site Index
 
Nut Graf
- More Nut Graf
 
Free Speech
- More Free Speech
 
Open Gov't
- More Open Gov't
Big Brother
- More Big Brother
 
Shield Law
- More Shield Law
 
Video
- More Video

Nation
White House may disclose 'X-Files'

Could open government mean information about extraterrestrials?
- More from Nation
 
World
From Brazil to Canada: a cold challenge

The number of Brazilians immigrating to Canada is soaring.
- More from World
 
Culture
'Watchmen' review: it's rated R?!?
Watchmen - image from Warner Bros. Entertainment
"Watchmen" takes superheroes to a violent new level.
- More from Culture
 
Progress
The polluted price of progress
Image courtesy of Flickr's Salim Virji
For better or worse, pollution has byproducts that help more than harm.
- More from Progress

About Fire in a Theater
Fire in a Theater compiles the most important and most interesting world news on free speech, open government, Big Brother, media rights and other topics First Amendment freaks care about.
Latest from Bonnaroo News
    - More from Bonnaroo News
Cartoons by Andy Marlette
    - More Cartoons

New at TheSequitur.com

Blogroll



Share, Syndicate and Socialize




Add to MyYahoo!
Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Add to Newsburst
Add to Google
Add to My AOL
Add to Pluck
Subscribe in FeedLounge
Add to Windows Live
Add to NetVibes
Subscribe in Rojo
Subscribe in Bloglines
Add to MyMSN
Add to Plusmo for your cellphone
Add to PageFlakes
Add to Technorati
Add to BlinkBits

Get our Widget -- Put TheSequitur.com headlines on your Web site.


Join other friends of TheSequitur.com ...
Join other friends of TheSequitur.com at MySpace.

TheSequitur.com on Facebook

TheSequitur.com on Twitter





TheSequitur.com Site Index

Nation

World

Culture

Progress

Nation Blog

World Blog

Culture Blog

Progress Blog

Nation Video- Nation Video Feeds

World Video- World Video Feeds

Culture Video - Culture Video Feeds

Progress Video- Progress Video Feeds

Editorial Page

Morning Coffee

Fire in a Theater

Bonnaroo News

Cartoons

Administration
About Us
Submissions
Corrections
Advertising
Donate
Opportunities
Sitemap

Home | About Us | Submissions | Opportunities | Donations | Advertising | Widget | DMCA | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Login
The Sequitur Media family of Web sites: TheSequitur.com | MorningCoffeeBlog.com | FireInATheater.com | BonnarooNews.com
Copyright 2005 - 2009 | Sequitur Media, LLC | All Rights Reserved